Update on RV’s engagement with the PES and Soil Health Working Group
This year in March, the Payment for Ecosystem Services and Soil Health Working Group picked up their work after their break in 2020. Rural Vermont had used the year off to partner with the White River NRCD and the Center for Agriculture and Food Systems at Vermont Law School to conduct legal research to create an overview of the working groups process to date under consideration of their legislative charges. The CAFS report was shared
with old and new working group members; as well as
to inform the Vermont Commission on Native American Affairs; and
To inform farmers in a subsequent series of farmer discussions on PES led by the conservation districts with critical support from UVM. Rural Vermont provided stipends to compensate farmers for their participation in this format.
At the first working group meeting of 2021, Rural Vermont shared key findings of the CAFS report via public comment.
The findings suggested to not focus on the development of a new program without also generating an inventory of practices and their related financial incentives by existing federal and state programs to enhance soil health and crop resilience, increase carbon storage and stormwater storage capacity, and reduce agricultural runoff into waters as pursuant to its authorizing legislation.
As a fundamental step Rural Vermont also echoed the CAFS report calling on the working group to include the voices of Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) farmers and stakeholders in the process to ensure the proposal incorporates equity and combats systemic racial inequities in our food system. In further collaborations with CAFS and partners, including Conservation Law Foundation, Stephen Leslie (Cedar Mountain Farm), and working group member Cat Buxton (VT Healthy Soils Coalition), Rural Vermont submitted a proposal:
to strategically and equitably survey and include farmer voices in the decision making process; to use some of the unexpected $250K in funding made available through H.315(2021) to facilitate this participatory process; and
to compensate stakeholders for their participation, including farmers and working group members that currently don’t receive compensation.
Excitingly both recommendations are actively being worked on by the working group. The working group approached their work this year from begin on differently and formed three task groups (Economic, Soil Health, Program Development) instead of focusing on webinars. Originally the program development task group began to inventory existing programs and sparked an interest and support for the participatory piece as well. Now both subjects will be part of the limited number of summer projects while the working group itself will reconvene in September. Progress of the other two task groups is about finding the scale on which to measure and act (farm vs. field); a definition and unit price for soil health or other Ecosystem Services - these and more conversations still face a lot of open questions. The good news is that the legislature did extend the working groups timeline for 2022, with legislative recommendations to adapt pre-existing programs and/or to establish new ones due in Jan 2023.
Did you know? About the Vermont Soil Health Policy Network that Rural Vermont co-initiated in fall 2020 to facilitate crosspollination among soil health initiatives? Check out this presentation to the PES & Soil Health working group, presented by Jennifer Byrne (Conservation District Manager of the White River NRCD) for the VT Soil Health Policy Network steering committee. Contact Caroline@ruralvermont.org if you want to get involved.